Does spinning make your butt bigger?

My sister swears it’s true — and I must say, her butt does look bigger since she started spinning classes a few months ago.

If this is a myth, as most fitness instructors say, it’s a fairly prevalent one — googling that question generates more than 2 million responses. A friend who’s a pretty serious cyclist — and actually wishes her backside had a bit more shape — says she’s never noticed an increase in size, just muscle tone. “My former personal trainer assures me it’s a myth,” she said.

The problem, if there is one, likely comes from the resistance dial.

“To build the large quadriceps and glueteal muscles you fear, you’d have to use a very difficult gear for repeated and extended periods of time,” reads the answer to this FAQ on spinning.com. “During Spinning class, climbs usually don’t last for more than a few minutes—not enough time to (build) bigger legs or a bigger butt.”

Mike Cola, a personal trainer and gym owner who runs fitnesscontrarian.com, has heard this complaint often enough that he’s formed a theory about it. According to Cola, what may be happening to some highly motivated dieting spinners may be an inadvertant form of glycolitic super-compensation, a body building technique used to increase the size of muscle cells.

“This is what I think is happening to some of my clients and their friends who think their legs are getting bigger from spinning,” Cola wrote. “They are most likely eating very little to watch their weight and spinning class is depleting all their carbohydrate stores. Then after one too many spinning classes, they get ravenously hungry and over eat. Their legs then get primed for increased carbohydrate storage, which results in bigger legs.”

I don’t know about that. But I do know that in the one spinning class I attended, Traci definitely was twisting that resistance knob more turns than anybody else in the room, including me. After comparing notes with one of her instructors recently, they decided she ought to focus on more speed, less resistance.

This entry was posted in running/fitness, Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Does spinning make your butt bigger?

  1. klp5d@yahoo.com says:

    I started spin class over the summer. I am long and lean (or as some would say skinny). I believe it depends on your body. I have to really work at it if I want to bulk up any muscle group…but my butt will bulk up after just about anything. My butt has grown two inches from spin..and I have only taken 6 classes. But that is MY butt..everyone’s body is different.

  2. IDALIA says:

    I BEEN TAKING SPINNING CLASS FOR 2 MONTHS & I BEEN TOLD AND NOTICED THAT I HAVE FIRMER LEGS,THIGHS & FLATTER STOMACH PLUS MY BUTT IS MORE TONE ,,HAPPY WITH RESULTS

  3. ChillgrlV says:

    I started cycling and spinning three years ago. I’ve always had a big butt and thick thighs. I noticed after a short while of spinning and road cycling that my thighs were leaner and my butt more toned. For me, it helped reduce excess body fat and gave me a lean appearance. My jeans fit way better! I recently stopped cycling for 6 months and I’m starting to get banana rolls so I would have to say the proof is in the pudding. Going back to the bike ASAP!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s